Hayek distinguishes between law - those rules that have evolved spontaneously and are unplanned and integrated into our expectations - and legislation - those rules designed by individuals or legislators and enforced through the threat of force. Similar to Don Boudreaux's lunch room example (listen at http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2006/12/boudreaux_on_la.html), I have noticed in my classrooms that after the first day of class, students almost always sit in the same seat. Thus the seat they choose on the first day, now becomes theirs. It's the law of the classroom, although there is no enforcement mechanism.
One difference is that we know law, but cannot possibly know all of the legislation that is continuously passed. Tennessee recently passed legislation that outlaws the sharing of internet passwords for Netflix and other sites.
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/washington/2011/06/tennessee-outlaws-sharing-passwords-to-hulu-netflix-rhapsody-and-others.html
This type of legislation is unnecessary, since companies such as Netflix can determine whether I have shared my password with all of my friends. They can easily remove my account if too many people are using it. Netflix does not need the government to collect a $500 fine from me if I share my password. I have the contract with Netflix not the government. If I do share my password with all my friends, then and Netflix can either cancel my subscription or use the courts to sue me for breach of contract.
The question we need to ask is "Who benefits from this legislation?"
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular entries
-
As Europe’s leaders struggle to convince markets that their Greek debt problem-resolution-proposals are actually viable, and will really do ...
-
China has its fingers in nearly every aspect of global financing as the following articles show. San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge Now Made i...
-
Basically, following up on this post earlier this month I wish to report that the 3 month euro libor rate is still stuck where it was, way ...
-
There is indeed a 100% guaranteed safe way to own gold and silver. But before addressing how, a basic question must first be addressed: Why ...
-
With the timing of the latest G20 meeting set to coincide with the run-in to the German elections acrimonious debate has not been absent , b...
-
Europe's manufacturing and service industries contracted in September at the fastest pace in nearly seven years as continuing problems i...
-
Bloomberg is reporting EU Renews WTO Complaint Over U.S. `Zeroing' Practice . The European Union wants World Trade Organization judges t...
-
Why have routine (and not so routine) medical and dental services performed in the US when you can have them done cheaper elsewhere and get ...
-
Reader Jeddy spots what he thinks is a conflict in my typical "privatization" message and inquires Hello Mish I'm confused abo...
-
Equity futures are down sharply in Asia, Australia, Europe, and the US in conjunction with data that shows manufacturing in China is barely ...